-->

Abbott Analytical Products



Reference:


Through-Wire Wooden Fishing Lure:

Brief Summary of Project:

This project, 021_fishlure, employed previously gained FreeCAD knowledge, experimentation with FreeCAD Parts.Revolve workbench.tool, incorporation of four flute endmills, and cable wrapping loops. The results, lure style 021.4, is a stronger, realistically shaped crank style lure. Fish actually took an interest in this prototype.

Pond testing, lure confirmed the need for a lip. Various lip designs were attempted using materials such as plexiglass and thin sheet metal. Finally a potential, feasible 3D printer design was discovered. However, that design was determined to be too difficult to insert/mate with the 021.4 style lure body. A modification of that 3D printer design and of the 021.4 style lure was employed. A discussion of the modifications to the lip's 3D design can be found as a "make" of the original lip design. The FreeCAD project 021 was modified to include a pocket cut on the bottom of the lure to support mating with the lip with a modest negative three degree drop. The documents for the 3D printer lip and the pocket cut are provided further below in this section.



Image 11: Realistic Wooden Lure ready for assembly, final expoy coating, hardware, and water trials.

Field Testing The 021.4 style lure was successfully "pond tested". The addition of the luminescent plastic lip greatly improved the dive and play characteristics. It may have also improved the over-bouyant behavior. A second test session proved to be exciting with ,Fishing lure+lip 21.4.2. After a couple of lazy casts, a "bass" struck. The fish was played to a point where a rocky culvert empties into the pond. The fish could not be netted and was lost. Later during that second test session, Fishing lure 21.4.2, almost survived a severe collision with a metal fence during casting. The lip was destroyed and lost one treble hook. But the body survived. A new lip was installed, new treble hook was installed, and epoxy sealant was applied as needed to seal the lip and body.


Prototype:
016.2.1. FreeCad Project 016. Two Flute First Example
021.2.1. FreeCad Project 021. Two Flute First Example
021.4.1. FreeCad Project 021. Four Flute First Example
021.4.2. FreeCad Project 021. Four Flute Second Example

General Observation 016.2.1 021.2.1 021.4.1 021.4.2
Responded well to casting
Good distance
Good control even in light wind
Dual trebble hooks played well
Cranking/Playing
Settled evenly in water
Pulled evenly/straight in water
Responded with diving/wiggle
Worked through vegetation
Durability
Sealant/colors held fast
Drag tree branch long surface
Comparable to other crank lures
Classic crank lure shape
Ultra-Light sample
Relative weight to sample
Confirmed need for dive lip
Response From Fish
Hits/Bites
Hooked/Played
Caught/Landed
Conclusion
Good to fish
Create next batch of prototypes
Add dive lips to prototype
Defer Decision
Scale of shape

No(1)
Yes
No

Yes
Yes
Yes(2)
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
NA
No

Yes
No
NA(3)
NA(4)
NA(4)

Yes
NA
Yes

No(5)
No(6)
No(7)
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
NA
No

Yes
Yes
No(4)
No(4)
No(4)

Yes
UNK(11)
Yes

UNK(5,11)
Yes
UNK(7,9,11)
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes(7)
Yes(8,11)

Yes
Good2Go
Yes(9)
Good2Go
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes(9.10)
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes(12)
Yes(12)
No(12)

Yes
Yes(13)
Yes(9)
Yes(13)
Yes

1. Ballast weights added to lower buoyancy.
2. Responded well with lip added.
3. Added lip since first pond trial.
4. Terminate design development.
5. Too buoyant.
6. Slight yawl/roll as cranked
7. Needs lip.
8. Large mouth bass landed on third cast.
9. Retrofit dive lip.
10. Lip added and pond tested.
11. Lip added and given to associate for testing.
12. Hooked, played, and lost due to angler's mis-handle landing.
13. Start batch of nine for bouyanccy testing.

Discussion of Process Flow
The FreeCAD project files, resulting gcode, and salient LinuxCNC support files for the Sherline Next Generation 8580 with Rotary Table/Right Angle are given below in seven part compressed file rar format. A high level view of contents of the compressed files is given directly below. Links in the next section lead to the downloadable seven compressed files.

  1. A file called dirlist which provides a working manifest of the zip file.
  2. Folder containing a more detailed a working checklist for moving through the milling process.
  3. FreeCAD project files for Lure and Finish Operations.
  4. The full collection of gcode for milling the lure objects.
  5. A folder containing supporting program modules with images which require loading to the LinuxCNC machine folders.
  6. The Cura 3D printer design project and gcode are available from the lucca82 Make Project at Thingiverse. That site also contains a discussion directly related to the 3D Printer aspect of the lip for the lure.

Download Actifcats

  1. Part1
  2. Part2
  3. Part3
  4. Part4
  5. Part5
  6. Part6
  7. Part7

gCode For Lure Milling:

gCode
Filename
Purpose Comment<
081.15_07_009_980_fishlure_probe.ngc Execute a probe along centerline Performed manually.
089.03_02_016_980_fishlure_flipper.ngc Flip workstock from 0 to 180 degrees Executed well
089.06_02_009_980_fishlure_reset.ngc Flip workstock from 180 to 0 degrees Executed well
092.01_06_021_973_057_ure_SideA_Top.ngc Executes waterline surface milling of SideA Executed well
092.02_06_021_973_057_lure_SideB_SplitFace.ngc Executes SideB milling for through wire placement Performed manually.
092.03_04_021_973_057_lure_SideB_Bottom.ngc Executes waterline surfacemilling of SideB Executed well
092.04_06_021_973_057_PinHoleOnly_lure_SideB_SplitFace.ngc Drills Pin Holes for SideB Performed manually.
092.99_05_021_973_057_outline_lure_SideB_Bottom.ngc Creates trace outline of SideBfor lip alignment Executed well
100.01_08_031_973_057_lipCut3dPocket_boxCheck.ngc Executes the pocket cut for lip Executed well

gCode Filename syntax
ggg.ss_vv_fff_ppp_xxx
    ggg: Identifier for gcode folder/family repository
    ss: Identifier for gcode within a folder/family
    vv: Revision numeric
    fff: FreeCAD project workspace
    ppp: Project within a FreeCAD project workspace
    xxx: Identifier assigned to a hybrid of a Project

Tool Table Entries

"stepper.var" Entries

5220 1.000000
5221 0.000000
5222 -0.605000
5223 -2.000000
5224 0.000000
5224 0.000000

Discussion of Design Process Flow

See the earlier crank lure and realistic lure for a discussion of the maturing steps in crank lure design. Instead of using a Side-1 and Side-2 (Right Half and Left Half) the perspective was changed to Dorsal {Top} Half and Belly {Bottom} Half. This change allows the compartmentalization of the design. The Dorsal Half has both eye buds and the primary shape of the lure. The Belly (Bottom} Half features include the Through Wire, the Belly Hook Loop Wire, and Alignment Pins Holes.


Dorsal Half/Belly Half:

The initial steps in the design differed from the earlier crank lure of Project 016. The Dorsal or Top Side was based upon an ellipse 2D shape. Using this shape as the outline, a continuous multipoint DraftWire 2D line was drafted from the left most point touching the x-axis to its right most point touching the x-axis. Using the Draft bench-revolve, the 3D Dorsal Half was created. With the Dorsal Half defined, it was then copied/pasted as the Belly Half. With the Belly Half shape now available, the Belly Half was modified from within the Draft workbench to generate the "desired" shape.

From that point forward the Dorsal Half and Belly Half were available for creation of Jobs and the associated *.ngc code. The Through Wire Processing was originally attempted as a separate CAD/CAM CNC gcode process. But common sense that it was better to create the Through Wire grooves, drill Belly Holes, Alignment Holes, "custom fit" craving of gaps for wire wraps manually, and adding a pocket cut to provide mating surfaces with the plastic lip. NOTE: For this early prototyping of the 021.4 style lure, the pocket cut was executed post-bandsaw separation because the need for the lip had not been confirmed. The difficulty in the alignment curved body lures presented with this deferred pocket cutting of the prototype strongly suggested that this pocket needs to be cut prior to the waterline surfacing while the centerline and factory edges of the woodstock can be employed.

A bandsaw was employed to separate the Dorsal Half and Belly Half from the workstock. The Dorsal Half and the Belly Half were then placed in a vise (with sacrifice wooden bumpers) to allow the drilling of the two alignment holes. The original centerlines (now significantly shortened) of the Dorsal Half were used for the drill operation setup.

Once the Alignment Pin Holes had been completed the two halfs were separated and then re-assembled. During the re-assembly, the Belly Half was now placed above the Dorsal Half such that the Alignment Pins could be inserted to allow exposure of the Belly Half's split face matching surface. With the Belly Half's matching surface exposed its centerline could be roughly verified between the head and tail points along the x-axis. The lures Through Wire groove was then scribe to a sufficient depth to allow the wire to just reach the top of the surface. The Belly Hook hole and its associated wrap "bore" hole were drilled. The accompanying "howto zip package" will provide a more detail set of steps as well as the pocket cut gcode and additional files to support this new operation.

The two lure halves were removed from the vise. The Through Wire Loops and Belly Hook Loops were created, assembled, and installed. Clearance "bore" holes were identified and created as needed to allow a "good" fit between the two halvs. This required a couple of assembly attempts using the Alignment Pins and then gently separating. During separation the both halves were examined to locate any points of conflict that might require additional "boring/cutting".

Once a "good" fit was achieved with the two halves and alignment pins were epoxied bonded. The excess lengths of the alignment pins were allowed to protrude from the Belly Half while being tangent with the Dorsal Half's surface. Painting coats were added as each dried. Avoid placing paint on the lip mating surface of the lure. Once the lure has dried the lip is ready to be epoxied into place. After that mating joint has cured a slanted slightly off-centerline pre-drill hole should be made such that the lip is pulled toward the mating surfaces of the lure. A small wood screw should then be fully inserted and then sealed. The body of the lure, immediate mating of the lip, and the lip's screw should then be receive sealant coat. The lure hardware was added after a "full" sealant cure in a solar oven.




Dorsal Half

Begin with the Draft Workbench
Create a Construction group
Within the new group create ellipse
Use the ellipse's Major/Minor Radius(from the Model)
Using the ellipse as an outline create a closed DWire 2D figure
Use Draft.Draft To Sketch to create a sketch version of this figure.
Take advantage of undocumented
feature/bug and ignore
non-constrained layers
From the Part Workbench
Revolve the Sketch of the lure to create Dorsal Half solid.
From the Part Design Workbench
Create a New Body called "TopHalf"
From the Part Workbench
Add the Dorsal Half solid to this new Body
Create sphere and place it as the right eye of the lure.
Create sphere and place it as the left eye of the lure.
Fusion of the lure/eyes as a Model.
From the Path Workbench
Create a Job Dorsal Half
Use Fusion as Model
Setup Stock/Tool
Use Waterline
Set start depth at 0.0 inch
Set final depth as needed.
Set parameters as needed
Select Waterline Operation
See Project 016 for Rehash of Job.Operation
Note that the Project 021 uses either Four Flute
End Mill for milling the surface.
Setup Contour Operation
Setup Dressup Tags Operation
Generate the waterline toolpath

Belly Half
Begin with the Draft Workbench
From the Model, Locate the sketch used to build the Dorsal Half
Copy this sketch
Use the existing Construction group
Paste this sketch
Rename this sketch for use on the BellyHalf
Double click this sketch to invoke the Sketch Workbench
Modify outline sketch to suit.
Gently grab a point on the DWire outline
Drag it a little and place in a new position.
Then grab and drag the next point.
From the Part Workbench
Revolve the Sketch of the lure to create Belly Half solid.
From the Part Design Workbench
Create a New Body called "BottomHalf"
From the Part Workbench
Add the Belly Half solid to this new Body
From the Path Workbench
Create a Job BellyHalf
Use Belly Half solid as Model
Setup Stock/Tool
Use Waterline Operation
Set start depth at 0.0 inch
Set final depth as needed.
Set parameters as needed
Select Waterline Operation
See Project 016 for Rehash of Job.Operation
Note that the Project 021 uses either Four Flute
End Mill for milling the surface.
Setup Contour Operation
Setup Dressup Tags Operation
Generate the waterline toolpath


Lip Pocket Cut
Begin with the Part Workbench
Import Lip STL model from Thingverse Crankbait with lip
Convert Lip STL model to a Mesh model.
Convert Lip STL Mesh model to a Solid.
Create a rendering of the Belly Half with "cut" For Lip.
Use the Previously create belly bottom
Create a Cutting Tool Composed of a Cone and Rectangle
From the Draft Workbench
Create the Actual Cut Pocket Model
Create a closed four corner projection of the cone cutting tool.
Z should be set at a negative value of the height
of the lip's matching surface.
Rotate the projection three degrees such that the
bow is higher than the stern part of the lip.
From the Part Workbench
Continue development of the Actual Pocket Cut Model
Create a extrusion of this projection with the height equivalent
to the lip's mating surface height.
Encase the cut model in a workstock block suitable to reflect
the lure's Belly workstock to obtain a model object of the pocket cut.
From the Job Workbench
Create a Job using the Pocket Cut Model as the Job's model
Under Operations Select 3D Pockets
From Pocket 3D select the bottom face of the Pocket Cut Model.
For Depths Start Depth select default and set
later. Set Finish and Step Down to suit.
For Heights and Operation select select the best for your equipment.
From the Combo View select the 3D Pocket operation
Set the Finish Depth to suit the negative value of the Lip height.
Once entered FreeCAD will begin a round of calculations
Verify the results display a number of toolpaths.

Post Process Lures
Post Process Lure
Generate Dorsal Half gcode
Generate Belly Half gcode
Generate Belly Outline gcode
From a text editor import a copy of the Belly Half gcode
Delete all Dressup and Surface gcode except for the last waterfall loop.
For the identified last waterfall loop perform a global Z
replacement such that Z now has a minimal depth
cut. For example Z=-0.01 in.
Save this document as the Belly Outline gcode.
Generate Lip Pocket Cut gcode


Move To Mill
Customize gCode
Add custom version control/history
Add custom content
Simulate Milling Operation
Practice Flip and Reset
Simulate Dorsal Half Waterline and Contour/Dressup
Simulate Belly Half Waterline and Contour/Dressup
Simulate Belly Outline and Lip Pocket Cut


Make Saw Dust



Design to gCode Process Flow With a collection of nine gcode files the project was moved to the mill. The Probe file was replaced with a level and a "scribe" point engraver to verify centerline on top. Then the work stock was flipped and the bottom centerline was verified. Verifcation of both top and bottom centerlines involved moving in the X axis along the centerline and "touching at several points. The combination of the 4-jaw chuck, right angle, level, centerline, and engraver/probe produced excellent results.

For a detailed, stepwise description of "how-to" create the lure from the CNC Mill to painting/coating and lip assembly view the process steps"how-to" document.

Project Photo Gallery:

Click Item to Expand

Shop
Setup
Operating Results Description

New Points
  • Used: y touch-off setting for P1 G54
  • to sync with centerline.
  • Used: vise alignment for drilling and scribing.


  • Points From Prior Projects
  • Chuck, Shims, Mill, Keypad,
    Rotary Table, Right Angle
  • Chuck, Shim, Centerline
  • Stock Centerline

  • SideB Ready for Milling
  • Milling Side-1
  • Flip To 180
  • Side-2 Ready for Milling
  • Simple Scribe
  • Dorsal/Belly Separation
  • Bandsaw Blade View
  • Blade Cut Width

  • Twisted Loops
    3 Locations
    20GA GS Steel Wire
  • Twisted Loop
  • 5/64 Drill Hole
  • Length to Match Belly Side Plus
  • Loop Dia to Suit
  • A/B Part Epoxy Sealant
  • "How-To" Create Loops Video
  • Other Helpful Videos


  • 3D Printer Lip
    Creation Presentation

    Repair Field Damaged Lure
  • Repair 21.4.2
  • New Features
  • Four Flute Milling
  • Glossy Eye Buds
  • Wrapped Loops
  • Dive Lip



  • Pond Testing

    Largest: 21 Inch Bass NC.


    First documented catch.


    Pleasant day.
    021 Lure
    Style: Crank
    Length:
  • Lure: 2.522 in.
  • Lure+Lip: 3.393 in.
  • Width: .796 in
    Height: .911 in
    Weight:
  • Lure: .343 oz
  • Lure+Lip: .446 oz

  • Painting
    1> Body
    1.1> Kiln Primer
    1.2> Acrylic. Green, Yellow, Orange
    2> EyeBuds: Black on Yellow
    3. A/B Part Epoxy Sealant

    Hardware
    Twisted Loops
    Split Rings #0
    Treble Hooks #8
    Wood Screw #4 Stainless Steel











    NOTICE: This site was fabricated for best viewing using Netscape 4.x, or a functionally equivalent browser.


    Please send comments or questions using e-mail, voice telephone at 919-846-7705. (Last update: Nov 25, 2019 tar)